glossier
No 1. Pencil Creamy Long-Wearing Eyeliner
$16.00Grade A+ (95/100)11 ingredients
Formula Quality95/100
Coverage 14%Long Wear 17%
50 Cheaper Alternatives
Products with similar formulas ranked by ingredient overlap, active match, and functional similarity.
Sort by
#1
Vegan Hydrating Lip Balm
SEPHORA COLLECTION
38% match3 sharedSave $11.00
$5.00
★ 3.87
#2
Mini Nudefix Cream Concealer
NUDESTIX
24% match4 sharedSave $7.00
$9.00
★ 4.33
#3
Sheer Matte Lip Balm
SEPHORA COLLECTION
38% match4 sharedSave $6.00
$10.00
★ 3.70
#4
Holiday Surprise Makeup Gift Set
SEPHORA COLLECTION
24% match3 sharedSave $6.00
$10.00
★ 5.00
#5
12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner
SEPHORA COLLECTION
35% match4 sharedSave $5.00
$11.00
★ 4.06
#6
Ultra Shine Lip Gloss
SEPHORA COLLECTION
32% match3 sharedSave $4.00
$12.00
★ 4.42
#7
Mini SEA Power Flex Full Coverage Vegan Concealer
tarte
24% match3 sharedSave $4.00
$12.00
★ 4.50
#8
Ultimate Gel Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
SEPHORA COLLECTION
32% match4 sharedSave $3.00
$13.00
★ 4.08
#9
Mini Eye Primer
Anastasia Beverly Hills
22% match3 sharedSave $3.00
$13.00
★ 3.69
#10
Mini Sketch & Set Brow Pencil and Tinted Gel
tarte
29% match4 sharedSave $2.00
$14.00
★ 3.38
#11
Balm Dotcom Lip Balm and Skin Salve
glossier
28% match3 sharedSave $2.00
$14.00
★ 2.94
#12
Mini Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil
Benefit Cosmetics
36% match3 sharedSave $1.00
$15.00
★ 4.23
#13
Satin Hydrating Lipstick
SEPHORA COLLECTION
34% match5 sharedSave $1.00
$15.00
★ 4.77
#14
Rouge Lacquer Long-Lasting Lipstick
SEPHORA COLLECTION
31% match4 sharedSave $1.00
$15.00
★ 4.12
#15
Mini SEA Mermaid Skin Hyaluronic H2O Serum
tarte
22% match4 sharedSave $1.00
$15.00
★ 3.11
#16
Mini Hello Happy Flawless Brightening Foundation SPF 15
Benefit Cosmetics
22% match3 sharedSave $1.00
$15.00
★ 3.74
#17
JuiceBalm Vegan Tinted Lip Balm
Tower 28 Beauty
34% match4 shared
$16.00
★ 4.52
#18
Quickliner For Lips Intense Lip Liner
clinique
49% match5 shared
$17.50
#19
Lip Glowy Balm
laneige
38% match3 shared
$18.00
★ 4.39
#20
Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation
Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez
37% match4 shared
$18.00
★ 4.55
#21
Plush Pout Lip Gloss
Artist Couture
36% match4 shared
$18.00
★ 4.42
#22
NORVINA Chroma Stix Makeup Pencils
Anastasia Beverly Hills
34% match4 shared
$18.00
★ 4.19
#23
Lidstar Long-Wearing Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow
glossier
29% match4 shared
$18.00
★ 3.92
#24
#LIPSTORIES Natural Wonders Lipstick
SEPHORA COLLECTION
27% match5 shared
$18.00
★ 3.25
#25
Hydra-Peptide Lip Butter with Mini Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil
NUDESTIX
27% match5 shared
$18.00
★ 4.60
#26
Golden Hour All Over Illuminator
SEPHORA COLLECTION
27% match3 shared
$18.00
★ 4.12
#27
Ultralip High Shine Lipstick with Hyaluronic Acid
glossier
23% match3 shared
$18.00
★ 4.35
#28
Gloss Shot Hydrating Lip Gloss
Kaja
34% match4 shared
$19.00
★ 4.63
#29
Lip Bento Balm + Scrub
Kaja
25% match3 shared
$19.00
★ 4.14
#30
Line It Up Clean 24-Hr Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
GXVE BY GWEN STEFANI
55% match7 shared
$20.00
★ 4.26
#31
XO Vinyl Lip Cream Lip Gloss
KVD Beauty
44% match3 shared
$20.00
★ 4.46
#32
Mini Luminous Blur Stick Primer
MILK MAKEUP
41% match3 shared
$20.00
★ 3.16
#33
SEA Surfer Curl Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
tarte
40% match4 shared
$20.00
★ 4.03
#34
Underlined Kajal Clean Waterproof Long-Wear Eyeliner
Kulfi
40% match5 shared
$20.00
★ 4.56
#35
Kind Words Matte Lipstick
Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez
37% match4 shared
$20.00
★ 4.53
#36
Make No Mistake Foundation & Concealer Stick
SEPHORA COLLECTION
34% match3 shared
$20.00
★ 3.90
#37
Mini Soft Butterfly Kisses Eyeshadow Palette
Violet Voss
34% match3 shared
$20.00
★ 5.00
#38
Surfproof Easy Glider Eye Definer Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
caliray
33% match3 shared
$20.00
★ 4.19
#39
Creamy Kohl Longwear Eye Pencil
huda beauty
44% match4 shared
$21.00
★ 4.87
#40
Power Line Plumping Lip Liner
Buxom
30% match4 shared
$21.00
★ 4.09
#41
Midnight to Morning Hydration Set
laneige
25% match3 shared
$21.00
★ 4.26
#42
Pout to Get Real Clean Overlining Lip Liner
GXVE BY GWEN STEFANI
36% match4 shared
$22.00
★ 4.16
#43
Dew Wet Hydrating and Highlighting Balm
Danessa Myricks Beauty
36% match3 shared
$22.00
★ 4.04
#44
Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
stila
35% match4 shared
$22.00
★ 3.90
#45
Infinity Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
MILK MAKEUP
35% match4 shared
$22.00
★ 4.62
#46
Dreamy Gleamy Holiday Lip Gloss Duo Set
Tower 28 Beauty
34% match4 shared
$22.00
★ 4.69
#47
Ultimate Ozone Multipurpose Primer Pencil
Urban Decay
34% match3 shared
$22.00
★ 4.05
#48
Silky Lip Oil
Artist Couture
34% match3 shared
$22.00
★ 3.44
#49
Optic Intensity Eco Gel Eyeliner Pencil
HAUS LABS BY LADY GAGA
33% match3 shared
$22.00
★ 3.75
#50
Deepwater Hydrating & Soothing Body Crème with Sea Moss & Niacinamide
CAY SKIN
30% match5 shared
$22.00
★ 4.58