Benefit Cosmetics
Cookie and Tickle Powder Highlighters
$35.00Grade A+ (95/100)11 ingredients
Formula Quality95/100
Coverage 40%Long Wear 14%
50 Cheaper Alternatives
Products with similar formulas ranked by ingredient overlap, active match, and functional similarity.
Sort by
#1
Artist Color Pencil Brow, Eye & Lip Liner
Make up for ever
36% match4 sharedSave $31.00
$4.00
★ 4.73
#2
Mini Nudefix Cream Concealer
NUDESTIX
26% match5 sharedSave $26.00
$9.00
★ 4.33
#3
Q10 Antioxidant Serum
The Inkey List
30% match3 sharedSave $25.01
$9.99
★ 4.31
#4
Mini Pocket Palette Eyeshadow Palette
SEPHORA COLLECTION
38% match3 sharedSave $25.00
$10.00
★ 3.87
#5
Holiday Surprise Makeup Gift Set
SEPHORA COLLECTION
27% match4 sharedSave $25.00
$10.00
★ 5.00
#6
12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner
SEPHORA COLLECTION
37% match3 sharedSave $24.00
$11.00
★ 4.06
#7
Boost + Lock Eyeshadow Primer
SEPHORA COLLECTION
40% match6 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 4.13
#8
Eye Shadow Singles
Anastasia Beverly Hills
40% match5 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 4.47
#9
Mini Roller Express Curling Mascara & Liquid Eyeliner Set
Benefit Cosmetics
37% match3 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 3.68
#10
Speak Love Glossy Lip Treatment Oil
LYS Beauty
35% match3 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 4.56
#11
Mini SEA Power Flex Full Coverage Vegan Concealer
tarte
29% match5 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 4.50
#12
Mini Signature Conditioner
dae
27% match3 sharedSave $23.00
$12.00
★ 4.10
#13
In A Dream World Iridescent Sheer Gloss
INC.redible
40% match5 sharedSave $22.00
$13.00
★ 4.14
#14
Ultimate Gel Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
SEPHORA COLLECTION
27% match3 sharedSave $22.00
$13.00
★ 4.08
#15
Mini Gentle Cleansing Foam Hydrating Makeup Remover
Sulwhasoo
27% match4 sharedSave $22.00
$13.00
★ 4.45
#16
Mini Eye Primer
Anastasia Beverly Hills
21% match4 sharedSave $22.00
$13.00
★ 3.69
#17
Eye Love Bloom Eyeshadow Palette
SEPHORA COLLECTION
33% match5 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 3.20
#18
Mini Stay Naked Correcting Concealer
Urban Decay
32% match5 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 3.91
#19
Mini Sketch & Set Brow Pencil and Tinted Gel
tarte
32% match5 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 3.38
#20
Deep Conditioning Treatment Hair Mask Travel
dae
31% match3 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 4.37
#21
Moisturizer Mini knockout brightening gel
tarte
30% match3 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 4.67
#22
Total Control Drop Foundation
nyx
28% match3 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
#23
Mini Hydra'Reset Intensive Recovery Glycerin Hand Mask
Fenty Skin
26% match3 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 4.23
#24
Clear and Cover Acne Treatment Cream Concealer with 2% Salicylic Acid
SEPHORA COLLECTION
22% match3 sharedSave $21.00
$14.00
★ 3.97
#25
Polyglutamic Acid Dewy Sunscreen SPF 30
The Inkey List
35% match3 sharedSave $20.01
$14.99
★ 4.39
#26
Tartelette Juicy Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow Palette
tarte
46% match5 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.67
#27
Bright Future Gel Serum Under Eye Concealer
SEPHORA COLLECTION
42% match5 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.03
#28
Trio Contour Face Palette
SEPHORA COLLECTION
36% match5 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.31
#29
Mini Fluff Up Brow Flexible Brow-Texturizing Wax
Benefit Cosmetics
36% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.88
#30
Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner- Travel Size
tarte
34% match4 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.47
#31
Mini BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara
Benefit Cosmetics
32% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.82
#32
Destinations Eye Palette
SEPHORA COLLECTION
31% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.92
#33
Mini Radiant Creamy Concealer and Afterglow Lip Shine Gloss Customizable Set
Nars
28% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.13
#34
Wishing You Blockbuster Multi-Use Makeup Palette
SEPHORA COLLECTION
28% match4 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.50
#35
Mini They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara
Benefit Cosmetics
27% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.13
#36
Mini Hello Happy Flawless Brightening Foundation SPF 15
Benefit Cosmetics
26% match4 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.74
#37
Mini SEA Mermaid Skin Hyaluronic H2O Serum
tarte
22% match5 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 3.11
#38
Mini TL Advanced Tightening Neck Cream PLUS for Firming & Brightening
StriVectin
19% match3 sharedSave $20.00
$15.00
★ 4.04
#39
Smooth + Blur Primer
SEPHORA COLLECTION
48% match4 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.67
#40
JuiceBalm Vegan Tinted Lip Balm
Tower 28 Beauty
34% match4 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.52
#41
Mini Better Than Sex Volumizing & Lengthening Mascara
Too Faced
33% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 3.71
#42
Weekend Warrior Tone Up Cream
SEPHORA COLLECTION
32% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 3.60
#43
Soft Matte Perfection Blush Duos
SEPHORA COLLECTION
32% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.27
#44
Crushed Glitter Lip Gloss
Melt Cosmetics
31% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 3.39
#45
Mini BB Blur Tinted Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 30
tarte
31% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 2.68
#46
Disney Fantasia and ONE/SIZE Versatile Complexion Brush
ONE/SIZE by Patrick Starrr
27% match4 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.33
#47
Mini Hair Oil
OUAI
25% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 3.99
#48
Mini Moisture Surge 100H Auto-Replenishing Hydrator Moisturizer
clinique
23% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.22
#49
Mini Halo Healthy Glow Tinted Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 25 with Hyaluronic Acid
smashbox
17% match3 sharedSave $19.00
$16.00
★ 4.39
#50
Mini Arch Brow Micro Sculpting Pencil
Hourglass
33% match3 sharedSave $18.00
$17.00
★ 2.40